4 Conversion Mistakes Holding Back Your SaaS Sign-Ups

If you’ve already been trying to convince web visitors to sign up for your SaaS trial, then we're sure you’ll agree with us on this:

Getting them to hit that signup button is not a small feat.

After all, driving tons of traffic to the site is relatively easy, particularly if you can afford to use paid advertising.

Convincing visitors to try your product, now that’s a different story.

But as it turns out, poor conversions are often a result of just a handful of mistakes that prevent potential users from signing up.

And in this post, we’ll show you what those conversion mistakes are, and how you could fix them to immediately lift your SaaS trial sign-ups.

Intrigued? Then let’s get to it.

Mistake 1. Offering a Weak Call to Action

Did you know:

90% of web visitors who read your homepage headline will also read the call to action.

Crazy, huh?

Particularly, if you consider how few of them actually act on it.

But as our friend Joel Klettke puts it (note, the emphasis is ours):

“Calls to action are hyper-critical to the conversion process, and incredibly easy to get wrong.”

For one, you might be displaying a weak CTA that fails to inspire your visitors to act. Here are a couple of ways how this might happen:

Your CTA Doesn’t Build a Personal Connection With a Visitor

Take the most common CTAs like “Submit” or “Signup” as an example. Although they clearly indicate the action a person should take, they’re difficult for a person to relate to.

When writing your call to action, try to connect with the person you’re trying to convince to sign up. As Joanna Wiebe writes in this piece on Copyblogger:

“A great rule of thumb when writing a call to action is to make your button copy complete this sentence:

I want to ____________”

And then, use whatever copy you’ve used to complete the sentence as your CTA.

Dropbox CTA

You Confuse Visitors With Too Many CTAs

We're sure you’ve heard about the paradox of choice theory. It says that when we’re faced with too many options to choose from, we simply decide not to take any action at all.

As a rule, your website should ask the visitor for one specific action. Adding more calls to action might result in a person failing to decide which action to choose, and ultimately deciding to leave your site.

You Don’t Make the Call to Action Stand Out Enough

It goes without saying, doesn’t it? If no one can see your CTA, they probably won’t click it either. Just take a look at this example. We marked the CTA on the page. But if we didn’t, would you still notice it?

Our guess is, no. At least, not without analysing all the elements on the page first.

Using the same colour scheme as the rest of the page has made the CTA blend in with the rest of the content, making it almost indistinguishable without digging through the page.

poor CTA example

To make your CTA stand out on a page:

  • Use contrasting colors
  • Make the CTA button big so that it draws attention to itself
  • Leave space around it to prevent it from blending with other elements

good CTA example

Mistake 2. Asking for Too Much Information

Tell us:

How much time do you think it should take for a visitor to sign up?

Well, let us help you out with this one.

The answer is, as little as possible.

You see:

Signing up for a trial is often an impulse decision.

The whole process typically looks more or less like this: a person finds your SaaS product, they recognise the name from other social channels, they get intrigued by your promise, and right there, on the spot, decide to take your product for a spin.

But you can easily obstruct that process by placing roadblocks on the person’s journey.

And the most common roadblock of them all is asking for too much information during sign-up.

Here, there’s even research to prove it:

Dan Zanzarella discovered that conversion rates go down with every new field you add to the signup form.

conversion rate by form fields graph

Unbounce reported a test in which shortening the sign-up form resulted in a massive 120% lift in conversions.


So, when designing your conversion forms, ask for only the most important information that you absolutely need to know.

And in the case of SaaS sign-ups, this typically means a person’s email and optionally, a password they want to use to log in to their account.

Accuranker requires you to fill in only one form – email – to sign up for a trial.


Mistake 3. Not Displaying Social Proof

Which option sounds better to you?

A SaaS product that can help you overcome your problem…

…or a SaaS product with thousands of satisfied users that can help you overcome your problem.

Stupid question, right?

You’d obviously prefer a product thousands of people have found valuable. There’s absolutely no doubt about it.

And that’s because, we often seek and use social proof to validate our choices, particularly when we’re unable to make a decision. 

Social proof is a trait of our behavior that typically activates when we’re unsure about what to do. We overcome this by imitating the behaviour of others, assuming that it is correct for a given situation.

A number of psychological experiments have proved social proof’s existence and influence on us. Many of them are listed in this guide to social proof.

But the most important aspect of social proof is that you can (and should) use it to convince visitors to sign up for your trial.

Displaying Social Proof Close to the Sign-Up Form:

  • Builds trust in your business
  • Adds credibility to your product
  • Helps a visitor to validate the decision to sign up
  • Simplifies their decision-making process

There are many ways to include social proof in your sign-up process. Here are the most common ones SaaS companies use:

Including data or stats from your users. Freshbooks’ call to action features a convincing statistic from their users.

Freshbooks social proof statistic

Accuranker lists the number of their happy customers.

Accuranker happy customers

Showing testimonials. Cultured Code displays a Twitter feed with messages from users satisfied with their product.

CulturedCode Twitter mentions

Displaying client logos, press mentions, and other peer validation data. Helpscout displays some of their customers right below the call to action.

social proof logos

Beacon combines the number of customers with testimonials to offer a compelling social proof to potential users.

Beacon review

Mistake 4. Failing to Prove Your Expertise

Look, there’s no point beating around the bush here:

Your potential users have many other choices apart from your product.

And even if you do everything right, write a powerful call to action, make it prominent, and back it up with a strong social proof, they might still sign up for your competitors’ trial.

And that’s because you’ve failed to prove your expertise.

Just consider these stats:

According to the 2014 state of procurement study by Accenture, 94% of B2B buyers report that they conduct some form of online research before purchasing a business product.

They’ll scour Google, but they'll also read your website and blog articles looking for information that will help them decide whether or not to sign up for your product.

consumer research methods graph

In fact, for the most part, they’ll want to conduct all the necessary research on their own. As many as 31% will not want to talk to you during that process (but might need some phone support if they come across issues they can’t solve). And 10% will not want any involvement from you at all.

sales representative involvement graph

So, how can you meet those expectations?

First, establish yourself and your company as thought leaders by publishing useful content your audience could use to overcome their most immediate challenges.

Then, expand your content strategy across other channels to target your potential users’ interest and spark a decision to try your product.


Getting potential users to sign up for a trial is getting more challenging by the day. But as it turns out, poor conversions are often a result of just a handful of mistakes that prevent potential users from signing up.

Luckily, eliminating those delivers an almost instant lift in conversion rates.